On this page 8 sections
Is seamless pipe stronger than welded pipe?
Short answer
Not inherently. Seamless pipe has no weld seam, so codes give it full joint efficiency and it is preferred for the highest pressures, sour and critical service. Modern welded and annealed pipe, fully tested, performs very well in most process duties and offers tighter wall tolerance and lower cost, especially in larger sizes.
Seamless vs Welded Pipe at a glance
| Seamless | Welded Pipe | |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacture | Pierced from solid billet | Formed from strip/plate and welded |
| Weld seam | None | Longitudinal or spiral |
| Wall tolerance | Wider (±12.5% typical) | Tighter |
| Sizes | Limited in large diameters | Economical at large diameters |
| Code weld factor | Not applicable | Joint efficiency may apply |
| Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Typical specs | A312 SMLS, A106, A335, API 5L | A312 WLD, A358, A53 E, API 5L ERW/LSAW |
Which should you choose?
There's no universal "winner": the right choice depends on service conditions, codes and cost. Share your conditions with us for a recommendation.
Joint efficiency in design codes
Some piping codes apply a weld joint factor to welded pipe unless additional examination such as full radiography is carried out. That factor can require a thicker wall, which is why seamless is common where design pressure is high.
Size and availability
Seamless stainless pipe is most economical in smaller sizes. Above about NPS 10–12, welded pipe, often to A358 for stainless, becomes the practical choice. See ERW vs seamless for carbon steel.
Learn more
Related guides, comparisons and articles
Frequently asked questions
Can welded pipe be used for steam?
Yes, where the design code and project specification allow it, usually with the code's weld joint factor or additional NDE.
How do I tell seamless from welded?
By the marking (SMLS or WLD/EFW) and certificate, and by a visible or etched seam line inside welded pipe.
What is the main difference between Seamless and Welded Pipe?
Seamless pipe has no weld seam and suits the highest pressures and critical service. Welded pipe offers tighter wall tolerance and lower cost, especially at larger diameters, and modern welded, annealed pipe performs very well in most process duties.
When should I choose Seamless?
High pressure, high temperature, sour or cyclic service.
When should I choose Welded?
General process, utilities and large-bore lines.